Recruitment
Recruitment agencies keep paying for the consultants who left
A recruitment agency's software is priced almost entirely per consultant: the CRM, the job boards, the sourcing tools, the CV database access. Consultant churn in agencies runs higher than in almost any other industry, and every leaver keeps their seats until someone reconciles the licence count against the desk count at renewal. Most agencies never do. Here is where the leaver seats hide, and the renewal-time habit that claws them back.
In recruitment, much of the software stack is priced per head. The CRM is per consultant. The job board postings and CV database access are per user or per slot. The sourcing and outreach tools are per seat. The phone system is per extension. When an agency adds a consultant, the stack cost goes up within the week, because the new starter needs access to work.
When a consultant leaves, nothing happens at all. Their seats do not hand themselves back. The licences sit exactly where they were, attached to an email address that no longer answers, invoiced at the same rate, until a renewal comes around and someone compares the number of seats being paid for with the number of desks that exist. In an industry where consultant turnover is high, that comparison is worth real money - and it is the one step the renewal process usually skips.
Churn is the industry's defining number, and the stack ignores it
Agencies plan around consultant turnover. It shapes hiring, commission structures, desk splits and forecasts. What it does not shape, in most agencies, is the software bill - because the software bill only moves in one direction on its own. Onboarding a starter forces a licence to be bought; offboarding a leaver forces nothing. The IT checklist disables the email account and recovers the laptop. The licence, invisible and prepaid, stays.
The asymmetry compounds through the year. An agency that starts January with 30 consultants, loses 8 and hires 9 has ended the year one head bigger - and, without a reconciliation, as many as eight orphaned seats wider, because each departure left licences behind and each arrival added new ones. The invoice reads 39 where the floor holds 31.
Nobody sees this happen, because it does not happen anywhere visible. It accumulates in the gap between the HR system, which knows who left, and the vendor invoices, which do not.
Where the leaver seats hide
The CRM or ATS. The core system, priced per consultant, often on an annual contract with the seat count fixed at signature. The number in the contract is the number from the day it was signed - which is not today's number in any agency with normal churn.
Job board slots and CV database access. Sold in bundles per user. A leaver's slot keeps being paid for; meanwhile a starter who needed one got a new slot added mid-term at the top-up rate, because nobody knew the free one existed.
Sourcing and outreach tools. The per-seat premium networking licences are the most expensive seats in the building. They are bought for named users, and a named user who resigned in March is still a named user on the September invoice.
The phone and dialler system. Per extension, per month. Extensions outlive their owners as reliably as anything in the stack.
Compliance and referencing tools. Background checking, right-to-work verification, contractor payroll portals - per user, quietly, on the card of an office manager who left last year themselves.
The renewal is the only day the count gets corrected
Mid-term, most of these contracts will not let you hand seats back - reductions take effect at renewal or not at all. That makes the renewal date the one day of the year the leaver seats can actually be removed, and the notice period the deadline for asking. Miss it, and the corrected count waits another full year while the old count keeps invoicing.
An illustrative 30-consultant agency running a CRM at £780 per consultant per year, premium sourcing seats at £6,000 a year for eight named users, and job board access at £14,000 for a 25-slot bundle is carrying roughly £85,000 of per-head software. If churn has left five CRM seats, two sourcing licences and four board slots orphaned, the excess is about £18,000 a year, paid to vendors for people who no longer work there. The correction takes one afternoon, once, at the right time. The wrong time is any of the other 364 days.
The renewal-time reconciliation
- Build the contract register first: every per-seat tool, its renewal date, its notice period, and the act-by date the notice period produces. Twelve months of invoices and one card statement will surface tools the directors have forgotten exist.
- Put the act-by dates where the agency already looks, not in a spreadsheet nobody opens. The deadline for cutting seats is the notice deadline, not the renewal date.
- Six weeks before each act-by date, pull two lists: current consultants from the HR system or payroll, and named users from the vendor's admin panel. The difference is the money.
- Check last-login dates on the survivors. A seat belonging to a current employee who has not logged in for five months is a live question for the manager, not a licence to renew by default.
- Send the reduction with the renewal notice, in writing, inside the window. The vendor's renewal quote will roll the old count forward; reply with the reconciled one.
Renewly holds the register for you. It reads each agreement, pulls out the renewal date and the notice period, calculates the last day you can act, and alerts you before that day passes - so the seat reconciliation happens while it can still change the invoice, not after the old count has rolled forward for another year.
